MZ Answers Mail

"MZ, how can we keep ALL of the land and NOT become a minority in our own land? The only way to do that is to ethnically cleanse them - and you know full well that that's impossible? The religious Zionists have no answer to this question, just rhetoric."
-Patriot

Excellent question, Patriot. The premise of your question is that Jews must only be in control of the land in which they are the majority population. Well, using that rationale, in Gush Katif Jews were vitually 100% of the population, and yet were still expelled by force! Why?

Well, the Arabs basic reason for wanting to kick out the Jews is that they claim this is THEIR land. THEY claim it as their own, and any Jewish presence is considered trespassing. I know in Israel there are towns which are mostly arab alongside towns which are mostly Jewish. This has been accepted by the Jewish State as a co-habitation without discrimination.

Yet, Jews still must be expelled from Gush Katif? By what logic? None, aside from the fact that they have the nerve to be Jewish. If we begin expelling Jews for being Jewish we are also saying that moslems need to be expelled for being islamic. In your response you claim it is not possible to expel the moslems. By whose measure?

Certainly, if Jews are to be expelled from communities which are within the boundaries of Eretz Israel - as well as the borders won by Israel in battle - than surely Arabs need to be reciprically expelled at a minimum.

Religious Zionists understand that in the case of a single nation at war over the right to govern, we will either be defeated and concede it to the Arabs, or else we will be victorious and expel the moslems to make the Jewish State whole - as well as wholly Jewish.

I suggest you read Benny Elon's Plan for Peace. You will learn a lot about why it is justice for all parties to expel the moslems from Eretz Yisroel and back to their native, moslem land. There really is no other way.

-MZ